Does anyone know if the Excalibur Shop carries good quality replica armor?

I bought a chest piece last year. It held up surprisingly well during a big skirmish. Just be careful with the rivets.

Honestly, I'd recommend checking out other vendors. Their stitching quality is noticeably superior to Excalibur's pauldrons. You'll save money and look better.

The basic vambraces are fine. Nothing fancy. Good for beginners.

I had a terrible time with their leather strapping. It started cracking after just two uses. Seriously, look elsewhere for durability.

Did you check their return policy? That might be more helpful than reviews.

I found that the metal finishing is okay, but the underlying material is thin. For moderate action, you really need to reinforce the joints yourself with external padding. Don't trust the shop's assembly alone.

If you are going for high-impact LARP, do not buy anything from them. Their gear is purely cosmetic. For anything that needs to withstand real hits, you need specialized, reinforced materials. I spent a fortune on a custom set from a local artisan, and it was worth every penny because it actually protected me. I recommend researching local blacksmiths or dedicated armor makers instead of relying on online shops for critical gear. Look for people who use actual boiled leather and proper riveting techniques, not just glued-on pieces. Seriously, your safety and immersion depend on it, so please spend the extra time researching quality craftsmanship rather than just the lowest price point. Trust me on this one.

The greaves are decent. Good value.

I think they are fine if you keep your expectations low. They are definitely entry-level gear. Don't expect movie quality, but they won't fall apart in a single afternoon of fun.

The metal paint chips easily. It looks cheap.

Look for reviews that mention specific stress points, like the elbow joints or the shoulder harness. Those are where the quality really shows. I found a local group that recommends a specific, smaller vendor who uses better quality stitching and metal alloys.